Where did you buy those new studs?
I ordered them from Peter DeBella Jeep Parts. Pete's seems like a good guy, a little rough at times (a straight talker with harsh language, which I don't mind), but honest. Since I have an affinity for NOS parts and he's sort of my defacto store for NOS, I've ordered a bunch of stuff from him over the past year. I've never had any issues with anything I've ordered. I contacted him this morning and Pete's looking into it. I'm sure he'll figure it out and we'll workout a fair good solution regardless of the outcome.
Yesterday I did a ton of research and there seems to be 2 different sizes (maybe 3). I found and ordered some on eBay that appear to match those currently installed. Here's a photo of the ones from eBay. As you can see the knurling shank and overall length appear to match those originally installed.
Here's a stud comparison I found surfing Google, interestingly they all state M38 even though they're different sizes. The first stud looks identical to the originals and the new ones match the second stud. I'm thinking there may have been some variation on the thickness of the wheel flange over the years, but I really don't know.
In the end I'll post what Pete says and what happens when the eBay studs arrive.
Cheers -- James